harry potter and the half blood prince full movie

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince: A Look at the Inconsistencies in the Film Adaptation

The films have made some notable changes to the characters, including Cho Chang's age and her relationship with Harry Potter. However, it's the inconsistencies in the story that have raised eyebrows among fans of the book series.

One such inconsistency is the scene where Professor Quirrell dies. In the book, Harry was unconscious at the time, but in the film, he is shown to be awake. This raises questions about why Harry couldn't see Thestrals after Professor Quirrell's death in Sorcerer's Stone.

It's easy to assume that Harry was too young to comprehend his mother's death as an infant and therefore couldn't see Thestrals in his first year at Hogwarts. However, this explanation is not entirely convincing, especially given that Harry saw Cedric Diggory die at the end of his fourth school year.

The mystery surrounding Harry's ability to see Thestrals is eventually explained by Luna Lovegood, who reveals that you can only see them if you've witnessed death. This inconsistency highlights the differences between the book and film adaptations of the series.

Another notable inconsistency is the use of Polyjuice Potion in the films. In Order of the Phoenix, Harry uses the potion to impersonate Mad-Eye Moody, but his voice seemingly doesn't transform. This creates a discrepancy with the book description, which states that the potion changes both one's voice and vision.

The inconsistencies continue when Hermione uses Polyjuice Potion to become Harry in Deathly Hallows - Part 1, remarking on how terrible his eyesight is. However, this is at odds with the book description, which suggests that the potion takes on the entire appearance of the person you're becoming, including their vision.

Furthermore, Ron and Harry maintain their own voices when they become Crabbe and Goyle in the second film, despite the book describing the potion as changing one's voice. This inconsistency is highlighted by a scene where Harry, as Goyle, keeps his glasses on until Draco questions it, implying that he doesn't get Goyle's vision from drinking the potion.

In conclusion, while the films have made some notable changes to the characters and story, it's the inconsistencies in the narrative that have raised eyebrows among fans of the book series. The explanations provided by Luna Lovegood and the Polyjuice Potion scenes only add to the discrepancies between the book and film adaptations.

Harry potter and the half blood prince full movie